Starting seeds can be one of the most rewarding and exciting parts of gardening. Watching tiny seeds transform into healthy plants is such an amazing experience, but it can also be frustrating when things don’t go as planned. If you’ve ever struggled with poor germination, leggy seedlings, or mysterious die-offs, you’re not alone!

In this guide, we’ll help cover the dos and don’ts of seed starting, the most common reasons for failure, why soil type matters, and how to get light and heat conditions just right for strong, healthy plants.

The Dos and Don’ts of Seed Starting

The Do’s

1. Use Fresh Good Quality Seeds – Shop Seeds Here
   • Check the seed packet for the year it was packaged. Older seeds lose viability, meaning fewer will sprout.
2. Use a Quality Seed-Starting Mix
   • Seedlings need light, well-draining soil with the right nutrients. More on soil types below!
3. Provide Consistent Moisture
   • Keep the soil moist but not waterlogged. A spray bottle works great to avoid disturbing seeds.
4. Provide Proper Light and Heat
   • Most seeds need warmth to germinate and bright light to grow. We’ll cover this in detail further down.
5. Label Your Trays
   • It’s easy to forget what you’ve planted. Use labels to avoid mystery seedlings!
6. Thin Your Seedlings
   • Once seeds sprout, thin them out to one seedling per cell to give each plant room to grow.
7. Harden Off Before Transplanting
   • Gradually expose your seedlings to outdoor conditions before planting them in the garden to avoid shock.

The Don’ts:

1. Don’t Use Garden Soil, Outside dirt, or potting soil.
   • These type of soils are too heavy for seed starting and can contain pests and diseases.
2. Don’t Overwater
   • Overwatering can cause seeds to rot before they even sprout or lead to damping-off disease (a fungal infection that kills seedlings).
3. Don’t Skip the Light
   • Even if seeds germinate, they will become leggy and weak without enough light. A sunny windowsill often isn’t enough!
4. Don’t Ignore Temperature Requirements
   • Different seeds need different temperatures to germinate. For example, tomatoes love warmth, while spinach prefers cooler temps.

Common Reasons for Seed-Starting Failures

Even experienced gardeners encounter seed-starting problems. Here are the top reasons seeds fail and how to fix them:

1. Poor Soil
   • Using heavy, compacted soil can prevent seeds from germinating or cause seedlings to struggle.
2. Lack of Light
   • Without enough light, seedlings grow tall and spindly (a condition known as “legginess”) and are unlikely to survive transplanting.
3. Inconsistent Moisture
   • If the soil dries out, seeds won’t sprout. If it’s too wet, they’ll rot.
4. Wrong Temperature
   • Seeds won’t germinate if it’s too cold or too hot. Most seeds need 65-75°F to sprout.
5. Overcrowding
   • Planting too many seeds in one cell can cause competition for light, nutrients, and space.

Why the Soil you Choose Matters

The type of soil you use is one of the most important factors in seed starting. Garden soil or potting mix might seem like a convenient option, but they aren’t suitable for seedlings.

What to Use:
• Seed-Starting Mix:
• Light, fluffy, and well-draining.
• Usually contains a blend of peat moss or coconut coir, vermiculite, and perlite.
• Free of pests, diseases, and weed seeds.

What to Avoid:
• Garden Soil:
• Too heavy and compact.
• Can contain fungi, bacteria, and insects.
• Regular Potting Mix:
• Can be too rich and retain too much moisture for delicate seedlings.

Here are some seed starting mixes we have personally used and recommend

Selecting a high-quality seed starting mix is crucial for successful germination and healthy seedlings. Here are some top-rated options to consider:

Espoma Organic Seed Starter Potting Mix
This organic mix is lightweight and enriched with beneficial microbes to promote strong root development.

Coast of Maine Sprout Island Organic Seed Starter
Made with a blend of sphagnum peat moss, perlite, and composted salmon, this mix provides excellent moisture retention and aeration.

Burpee Organic Coconut Coir Concentrated Seed Starting Mix
A sustainable, peat-free option made from renewable coconut coir, offering excellent water retention and aeration.

Jiffy Organic Seed Starting Mix
This mix includes a blend of peat moss and vermiculite, providing a balanced environment for seed germination.

Black Gold Seedling Mix
A fine, lightweight mix that ensures good drainage and aeration, suitable for a wide variety of seeds.

FoxFarm Light Warrior Seed Starter
Designed to promote an environment beneficial to seed germination and root development, this mix includes soil microbes that enhance root efficiency and nutrient uptake. It also contains earthworm castings, providing gentle nutrition for seedlings and small plants.

PRO-MIX Organic Seed Starting Mix
This peat-based mix is ideal for germinating vegetable, flower, and herb seeds, as well as for starting cuttings. It includes natural ingredients and mycorrhizae to support strong root development and is OMRI-listed for organic gardening.

Avoid using regular garden soil or heavy potting mixes, as they can impede seedling growth due to poor drainage and potential pathogens. Investing in a high-quality seed starting mix sets the foundation for robust and healthy plants. When choosing a seed starting mix, look for products labeled as sterile and free from added fertilizers, as young seedlings are sensitive to high nutrient levels. A fine texture is also important to support delicate roots. Avoid using regular garden soil or heavy potting mixes, as they can impede seedling growth due to poor drainage and potential pathogens. Investing in a high-quality seed starting mix sets the foundation for robust and healthy plants.

Why Light is Important

One of the most common mistakes in seed starting is not providing enough light. Even if your seeds sprout, without enough light, they will grow tall, weak, and leggy as they stretch toward the light source.

Lighting Options

1. Grow Lights
   • The best way to ensure your seedlings get enough light is to use grow lights.
   • Position lights 2-4 inches above the seedlings and keep them on for 12-16 hours a day.
2. South-Facing Window
   • A bright, south-facing window can work, but often the light isn’t strong or consistent enough, especially in winter.
3. Rotate TraysIf you’re using natural light, rotate your trays daily to prevent seedlings from leaning.

Why Heat Matters

Heat is just as important as light for certain seeds. Some seeds, like tomatoes, peppers, and eggplants, require warm soil temperatures to germinate.

Tips for Providing Heat:

1. Use a Heat Mat
   • Place a heat mat under your seed trays to keep the soil warm.
   • Ideal temperatures for germination are typically 65-75°F, but check the seed packet for specifics.
   • Use a heat mat only when necessary. If the temperature is already warm enough in the area a heat mat may not be necessary.
2. Know Which Seeds Like It Cool
   • Not all seeds need heat to germinate. For example, lettuce, spinach, and peas prefer cooler temperatures.

Final Tips for Seed Starting Success

1. • Be Patient! Some seeds take longer to germinate than others for example, the Lisianthus and Eucalyptus take time to germinate and takes time from seed to full bloom
2. • Keep Notes. Use a simple notebook or a garden journal to track what you planted, when it germinated, and how it grew.
3. • Have Fun! Seed starting is an exciting process — enjoy watching your garden come to life from seed to bloom!

By following these tips and avoiding common mistakes, you’ll be well on your way to growing strong, healthy seedlings that thrive in your garden. Happy growing!

Looking for Seed Starting supplies? Let Epic Gardening help you get started! Shop our Epic Gardening Storefront to begin and let’s grow!

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. This means when you make a purchase through one of our links we will receive a small commission. Thank you for your support!